Multi-Actor Multi-Criteria Analyse (MAMCA) prof. dr. Cathy Macharis

Transcriptie

1 Multi-Actor Multi-Criteria Analyse (MAMCA) prof. dr. Cathy Macharis 30/01/2014

2 Stakeholders Oosterweel 2 Lecture doctoral school Gothenborg

3 Stakeholders DHL case 3 Lecture doctoral school Gothenborg

4 Sustainable Mobility and Logistics Growth Efficiency Employment Competivity Choice Economy Society Safety Health Accessibility Equity Sustainable Logistics And Mobility Environment Climate change Air quality Noise Land use Biodiversity Waste 4 Lecture doctoral school Gothenborg

5 Overzicht Stakeholder analysis 2 1 Stakeholder 1 Stakeholder m 4 Indicators Measurement methods Alternatives 3 C C n1 n1 C W 11 11n1 n1 C C C C W nm nm C Overall analyses (MCA) Ref. Altern scenarios W C W nm nm 6 Results Implementation Mitigation strategies +/0/- Deployment scenarios 7 Cathy Macharis 30/01/2014 5

6 Toepassing: Case Klein-Brabant Realisatie van een nieuw regionaal vervoersysteem in Vlaanderen. Waarom MAMCA? Verzamelen van de meningen van de verschillende stakeholders Cathy Macharis 30/01/2014 6

7 Toepassing: Case Klein-Brabant Streek langsheen Rupel & Schelde, in de stedendriehoek Antwerpen Brussel Gent Cathy Macharis 30/01/2014 8

8 Toepassing: Case Klein-Brabant Cathy Macharis 30/01/2014 9

9 MAMCA Stap 1 Stakeholder analysis 2 1 Stakeholder 1 Stakeholder m 4 Indicators Measurement methods Alternatives 3 C C n1 n1 C W 11 11n1 n1 C C C C W nm nm C Overall analyses (MCA) Ref. Altern scenarios W C W nm nm 6 Results Implementation Mitigation strategies +/0/- Deployment scenarios 7 Cathy Macharis 30/01/

10 Scenario 1: infrastructuur gebonden ontwikkeling Cathy Macharis 30/01/

11 Scenario 2: vraag volgende ontwikkeling (gebaseerd op bestaande mobiliteit) Cathy Macharis 30/01/

12 Scenario 3: Ruimtelijk gestuurde ontwikkeling (aanwezige waterstromen) Cathy Macharis 30/01/

13 MAMCA Stap 2 Stakeholder analysis 2 1 Stakeholder 1 Stakeholder m 4 Indicators Measurement methods Alternatives 3 C C n1 n1 C W 11 11n1 n1 C C C C W nm nm C Overall analyses (MCA) Ref. Altern scenarios W C W nm nm 6 Results Implementation Mitigation strategies +/0/- Deployment scenarios 7 Cathy Macharis 30/01/

14 Stap 2: Analyse van de stakeholders Cathy Macharis 30/01/

15 MAMCA Stap 3 Stakeholder analysis 2 1 Stakeholder 1 Stakeholder m 4 Indicators Measurement methods Alternatives 3 C C n1 n1 C W 11 11n1 n1 C C C C W nm nm C Overall analyses (MCA) Ref. Altern scenarios W C W nm nm 6 Results Implementation Mitigation strategies +/0/- Deployment scenarios 7 Cathy Macharis 30/01/

16 Stap 3: Criteria / stakeholder Cathy Macharis 30/01/

17 Stap 3: Bepaling van de gewichten Cathy Macharis 30/01/

18 Stap 3: Criteria & gewichten Cathy Macharis 30/01/

19 Stap 3: Criteria & gewichten Cathy Macharis 30/01/

20 Stap 3: Criteria & gewichten Cathy Macharis 30/01/

21 MAMCA Stap 4 Stakeholder analysis 2 1 Stakeholder 1 Stakeholder m 4 Indicators Measurement methods Alternatives 3 C C n1 n1 C W 11 11n1 n1 C C C C W nm nm C Overall analyses (MCA) Ref. Altern scenarios W C W nm nm 6 Results Implementation Mitigation strategies +/0/- Deployment scenarios 7 Cathy Macharis 30/01/

22 Stap 4: Indicatoren voorbeelden Criterium/Doelstelling Beschrijving/Definitie Indicator/Meetmethode Verkorten reizigerstijd In-Voertuig-Tijd (OV) Gemiddeld aantal knelpunten per km tracé Veiligheid Verhogen van de verkeersveiligheid en spoorveiligheid op kritieke punten Indicator: type OV-net (bestaand tegenover toekomstig) Natuur & Landschap Milieu lokaal Ruimtebeslag en versnippering, doorsnijden van waardevolle gebieden en ecosystemen tegengaan Geluid, fijn stof, luchtverontreiniging = lokale emissies zoveel mogelijk terugdringen Indicator: doorsnijden van waardevolle gebieden (natuur & landschap). Meetmethode: GIS. Indicator: # vermeden autokilometers + geluidsimpact Cathy Macharis 30/01/

23 MAMCA Stap 5 Stakeholder analysis 2 1 Stakeholder 1 Stakeholder m 4 Indicators Measurement methods Alternatives 3 C C n1 n1 C W 11 11n1 n1 C C C C W nm nm C Overall analyses (MCA) Ref. Altern scenarios W C W nm nm 6 Results Implementation Mitigation strategies +/0/- Deployment scenarios 7 Cathy Macharis 30/01/

24 Stap 4-5: Indicatoren & rangschikking Indicators Measurement methods Expert consultation Pairwise comparisons C1 Cj 4 E1 Ek C1 A1 A2 A3 Az A1 1 Cj A1 A2 A3 Az A1 1 5 A2 [1] A3 [1] [1] Az [1] A2 [1] A3 [1] [1] Az [1] Cathy Macharis 30/01/

25 Stap 5: Analyse & rangschikking Pairwise comparisons: AHP Ondersteunende beslissingssoftware: Expert Choice / D-Sight / Analyse per stakeholder Multi actor view Cathy Macharis 30/01/

26 MAMCA Stap 6 Stakeholder analysis 2 1 Stakeholder 1 Stakeholder m 4 Indicators Measurement methods Alternatives 3 C C n1 n1 C W 11 11n1 n1 C C C C W nm nm C Overall analyses (MCA) Ref. Altern scenarios W C W nm nm 6 Results Implementation Mitigation strategies +/0/- Deployment scenarios 7 Cathy Macharis 30/01/

27 Stap 6: Resultaten Vlaamse Overheidsdiensten Cathy Macharis 30/01/

28 Stap 6: Resultaten Performance Sensitivity for nodes below: Goal: Light rail in Klein-Brabant OV-operatoren Obj% Alt% De Lijn NMBS Mobilit OVERALL Infrastructuurgebonde Mobiliteitsgestuurd sc Ruimtelijk gestuurd sc Objectives Names Cathy Macharis 30/01/

29 Stap 6: Resultaten Gemeenten Cathy Macharis 30/01/

30 Kruibeke Weight of criteria in decimals.90 Score of alternatives in percentages 80% 70% % 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% Spatial scenario Tramification scenario Infrastructural scenario.00 00% Sustainable Access Integration OVERALL densification Reducing unattain. Integration park and Nature and travel areas public ride landscape time transport Cathy Macharis 30/01/

31 MAMCA Stap 7 Stakeholder analysis 2 1 Stakeholder 1 Stakeholder m 4 Indicators Measurement methods Alternatives 3 C C n1 n1 C W 11 11n1 n1 C C C C W nm nm C Overall analyses (MCA) Ref. Altern scenarios W C W nm nm 6 Results Implementation Mitigation strategies +/0/- Deployment scenarios 7 Cathy Macharis 30/01/

32 Stap 7: Implementatie Standpunt van elke Stakeholder Inventarisatie van passende beleidsmaatregelen om de invoering van het gekozen alternatief te vergemakkelijken Cathy Macharis 30/01/

33 Get in touch MOBI Pleinlaan Brussel 34