CURRICULUM VITAE CAREL E. SMITH (Februari 2012) PERSONAL DETAILS CURRENT POSITION PREVIOUS POSITIONS VISITING APPOINTMENTS EDITORIAL ACTIVITIES

Transcriptie

1 CURRICULUM VITAE CAREL E. SMITH (Februari 2012) PERSONAL DETAILS Carel Eduard Smith (1958), Meijers Institute of Legal Studies, Leiden Law School, University of Leiden, Steenschuur 25, 2311 ES Leiden, K B4.24, Mail: c.e.smith@law.leidenuniv.nl Webpage: EDUCATION Master Legal Philosophy & Methodology Degree, University of Utrecht, 1985 Propaedeutics Philosophy, University of Utrecht, 1989 Doctorate in Law, University of Leiden, 1998 CURRENT POSITION Associate Professor Legal Methodology (1,0 fte): Dean of PhD candidates, Graduate School of Legal Studies, Universiteit Leiden, 0,3 fte (2011 present) Director Research Programs Graduate School of Legal Studies, Universiteit Leiden, 0,4 fte (2006 present) Research Fellow, 0,3 fte (2006 present) PREVIOUS POSITIONS associate professor, Departement of Metajuridica, University of Leiden, 0,3 fte, ( ) assistant professor, Departement of Metajuridica, University of Leiden, 1,0 fte, lecturer Legal Theory, Departement of Metajuridica, University of Leiden, 1,0 fte ( ) member National Examination Board, School of Social Work & Administration ( ) lecturer Labour Law, School of Economics Theodorus Velius, Hoorn ( ) lecturer School of Social Work & Administration, MDGO De Oudenoord in Utrecht ( ) paralegal, Law Firm Parramore, Amsterdam ( ) VISITING APPOINTMENTS Visiting Professor Hastings University School of Law, San Francisco, U.S.A. (Spring 2006) lecturer Legal Theory, University of the Netherlands Antilles, Curaçao, secondment for 5 months a year ( ) EDITORIAL ACTIVITIES

2 2 member Editorial Board Leiden University Press (from 2012) associate editor Netherlands Journal of Legal Philosophy and Theory (R & R) (2010 present) associate editor Law & Method (2011 present) RESEARCH AND ADMINISTRATIVE MEMBERSHIP / LEADERSHIP Present member of the Faculty s Scientific Committee (2011 present) member of the Programmatic Steering Committee Joint PhD Programmes, Leiden University (2011 present) Dean of PhD candidates, Graduate School of Legal Studies, Leiden University (2011 present) director Research Courses Graduate School of Legal Studies, Leiden University (2011 present) member of the Selection Committee of the Meijers PhD positions, Leiden University (2010 present) member of the Board of The Netherlands Association for Philosophy of Law (2009 present) director of the Faculty s Master Talent Programme, Leiden University (2006 present) member of the LUF International Study Fund Commission LISF (2006 present) Previous chair of the Study Programme Committee (Opleidingscommissie), Faculty of Law, Leiden University ( ) member of the Study Programme Committee (Opleidingscommissie) ( ), Faculty of Law, Leiden University member Advisory Committee Research Master, Leiden Law School (2005) director Master Programme Encyclopedia and Philosophy of Law, Leiden University ( ) director BA programme Practicum en Methoden, Leiden University ( ) member of the Board of Studium Generale, Leiden University ( ) ORGANIZED SYMPOSIA/CONFERENCES (2012) Spring Meeting of the The Netherlands Association for Philosophy of Law, Vrije Universiteit, Amsterdam, June 2012, Down Freedom s Main Line (with D. Venema) (2011) Special workshop on "Analogy and Exemplary Reasoning in Legal Discourse", XXV. World Congress of Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy, August 2011 Frankfurt (with H. Kaptein & H. Kloosterhuis) (2011) Symposium Legal Argumentation, Rotterdam, June 2011 (with E. Feteris, H. Kloosterhuis, J. Pontier and J. Plug) (2011) Symposium Veellagige rechtssystemen n.a.v. het Algemeen Deel, veertig jaar later van W. van Gerven and S. Lierman, Leiden University, June 2011 (2010) Spring Meeting of The Netherlands Association for Philosophy of Law, Constitutionalism and the Framing of Democracy: An Iterative Tension, Universiteit Leiden, June 2010 (with B. van Klink and L. Francot Timmermans)

3 3 (2006) Conference The Rhetoric of Sincerity (with E. van Alphen and M. Bal), Leiden University, June 2006 (2006) Symposium series Vier dwarse perspectieven op Justitie (with E. van Alphen, M. Bal and the Department of Justice), Leiden/The Hague: (2005) Symposium Belangenafweging door de rechter with (J.H. Gerards and H. Kloosterhuis), Leiden University: October 2005 CONFERENCES & SYMPOSIA (2011) Presentation of The Rational Force of the Marginal: Deductive and Analogical Reasoning Revisited at the special workshop Analogical and exemplary reasoning in legal discourse in the framework of the XXV IVR World Congress of Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy, Frankfurt, August 2011 (2011) Presentation of Understanding value conflicts in law: towards a cultural vocabulary of law at the special workshop The Fact/Value Separation and its Relevance for Interdisciplinary Research in the framework of the XXV IVR World Congress of Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy, Frankfurt, August 2011 (2011) Presentation of Rechtspraak inzake groepsbelediging: van verbod naar verlof at the workshop Argumentatie en rechter at the 6th symposium Legal Argumentation Rotterdam June 2011 (2011) Speaker at symposium on Veellagige rechtssystemen n.a.v. het Algemeen Deel, veertig jaar later van W. van Gerven and S. Lierman, Leiden University, June 2011 (2011) Presentation of Rechtspraak inzake groepsbelediging: van verbod naar verlof at the workshop Argumentatie en rechter at the 6th symposium Legal Argumentation Rotterdam June 2011 (2011) Presentation of The Rhetoric of Literality in Law: Rules and Metaphor in Law at the international conference Rhetoric in Society III, Antwerp, January 2011 (2010) Guest lecture at Workshop on Legal Scholarship for PhD candidates, Amsterdam VU, May 2010 (2010) Guest lecture at Valedictory Symposium of Niels van Maanen, Amsterdam UvA, April 2010 (2009) Keynote lecture: Pré advies Het normatieve karakter van de rechtswetenschap: het recht als oordeel for the Netherlands Association for Philosophy of Law (VWR), Utrecht, June 2009 (2009) Guest lecture at Workshop on Legal Scholarship, Amsterdam VU, May 2009 Guest lecture Rechter en cultuur at RAIO conference, Egmond aan Zee, November 2008 (2008) Presentation of The case bound character of legal reasoning at conference Argumentation and the application of legal rules, Amsterdam UvA, November 2008 (2007) Presentation of Enkele varianten van taalkundige argumentatie at the workshop ( ) at the 5th symposium Legal Argumentation Rotterdam June 2007 (2007) Presentation of Legitimacy of the Ruling: a Formal Approach at the conference Legitimacy of High Court Judgments, The Hague, January 2007 (2006) Presentation of De verzwegen argumentatie bij grammaticale interpretatie at Symposium Legal Argumentation, Rotterdam, December 2006 (2006) Keynote lecture De rechtsstaat: van morele orde naar procedurele orde at Symposium Een Ander Justitie, Department of Justice, The Hague, May 2006 (2006) Presentation of Sincerity in Legal Argumentation Theory at the workshop Logic, Argumentation and Interpretation in the framework of the XXIII IVR World Congress of Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy, Granada, May 2005

4 4 (2004) Discussant at VSR Annual Meeting, Leiden, January 2004 (2003) Presentation of The Significance of Facts for Judicial Interpretation and the Legitimation of Legal Verdicts at the workshop Legislation and Judicial Decision in the framework of the XXI IVR World Congress of Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy, Lund, August 2003 (2003) Presentation Regels, beginselen en de valkuilen van de retoriek at the workshop Rechtvaardiging van Juridische Oordelen at the 4th symposium Legal Argumentation Rotterdam June 2003 (2002) Presentation of De beperkte betekenis van deugden als juridische categorie at the conference Rehten Plichten Deugden, Leiden, November 2002 (1999) Presentation of Redelijke argumentatie in een pluriforme samenleving at the workshop ( ) at the 3rd symposium Legal Argumentation Rotterdam June 1999 (1996) Presentation of De legistische erfenis: clear en hard cases at the workshop Rechtvaardiging van juridische beslissingen at the 2nd symposium Legal Argumentation Rotterdam June 1996 (1993) Presentation of Literaire interpretatie als ontoereikende metafoor voor rechtsvinding at the workshop Argumentatie en interpretatie at the 1rst symposium Legal Argumentation Rotterdam June 1993 PHD COMMITTEE 2008 doctoral thesis of Janine M. Ubink on In the Land of the Chiefs. Customary Law, Land Conflicts, and the Role of the State in Peri Urban Ghana, supervisor Prof. mr. J.M. Otto 2009 doctoral thesis of Pauline Memelink on De verkeersopvatting, supervisor Prof. mr. H.J. Snijders 2011 doctoral thesis of Hanneke C.K. Senden on "Interpretation of fundamental rights in a multitlevel legal system An analysis of the European Court of Human Rights and the European Court of Justice", supervisor Prof. mr. J.H. Gerards TEACHING EXPERIENCE Graduate Research Seminars/ PhD courses (English) (2006 present) Philosophy of Science for Lawyers (course) Legal Research: Elements (course) Descriptive and evaluative research (colloquium) Writing Clinic (colloquium) Linguistic Interpretation and Classification (colloquium) Legal Reasoning: Weighing and Balancing (colloquium) Justification of Normative Choices in Legal Research (colloquium) Graduate Seminar for PhD fellows SARFaL network (9 10 September 2010): Reasoning in Legal Research Master Talent Programme (English) (2006 present) Philosophy of Science for Lawyers (TP) Research Methods in Law (TP) Honours College (2010 present) Argumenteren in Recht en Maatschappij (HC)

5 5 Master (Encyclopedia and Philosophy of Law) ( ) Legal Methodology & Epistemology (privatissimum) Bachelor (1990 present) Law and Culture (Van Vollenhoven Instituut) (lectures) (2006 present) Law and Literature (with Prof. mr. H. Nieuwenhuis) (lectures) (2006 present) Legal Adjudication (BA 1) (lectures) ( ) Legal Ethics ( ) Introduction to law (BA 1) ( ) PUBLICATIONS Books / Monographs (forthcoming) (2013) Certainty in Law: Metaphors, Exemplars, and Institutions (manuscript) (2012) Analogical and Exemplary Reasoning in Legal Discourse, H. Kaptein, H. Kloosterhuis & C.E. Smith (eds.), Oxford: Hart Publishing 2012 (2012) Gewogen oordelen. Bijdragen aan het Zesde Symposium Juridische Argumentatie Rotterdam 24 juni 2011, E.T. Feteris, H. Kloosterhuis, H.J. Plug, J.A. Pontier & C.E. Smith (red.), Ars Aequi Libri 2012 (Published) (2010) Recht, beslissing en geweten. Beschouwingen naar aanleiding van Paul Scholten, A. Ellian, T. Slootweg & C.E. Smith (red.), Deventer: Kluwer 2010 (2009) The Rhetoric of Sincerity, E. Van Alphen, M.G. Bal en C.E. Smith (eds.), Stanford CA: Stanford University Press 2009 (338 p.) (2005) Regels van rechtsvinding, Den Haag: Boom Juridische uitgevers, 2de herziene druk 2007, 215 p. (2004) Ambtshalve aanvullen van rechtsgronden, Nijmegen: AA Libri 2004, 73 p. (2001) Theorie en praktijk van het casusoplossen, Maastricht: Shaker Publishing 2001, 182 p. (2000) C.E. Smith, M.A. Loth & H. Kloosterhuis, Inleiding tot de rechtswetenschap. Een encyclopedisch overzicht van het Antilliaanse en Arubaanse recht, Den Haag: Boom Juridische uitgevers, 2de herziene druk 2005, 222 p. (2000) Inleiding tot de praktijk van het recht, Maastricht: Shaker Publishing 2000, 192 p. (1998) Feit en rechtsnorm (diss. Leiden), Maastricht: Shaker Publishing 1998, 227 p. (1997) Rechtsfilosofische stromingen van de twintigste eeuw, P.B. Cliteur, B.C. Labuschagne & C.E. Smith (red.), Gouda: Gouda Quint 1997, 396 p.

6 6 Articles (Forthcoming) (2012) Rechtspraak inzake groepsbelediging: van verbod naar verlof, in: E.T. Feteris e.a. (red.), Gewogen Oordelen. Bijdragen aan het Zesde Symposium Juridische Argumentatie, Ars Aequi Libri 2012 (2012) The Rational Force of the Marginal: Deductive and Analogical Reasoning Revisited, in: H. Kaptein, H. Kloosterhuis & C.E. Smith (eds.), Analogical and exemplary reasoning in legal discourse, Oxford: Hart Publishing 2012 (2012) Revitalizing Paradigms: The Role of Exemplars in Legal Research and Education, Recht en Methode, 2012/1 (Published) (2011) The Vicissitudes of the Hermeneutic Paradigm in the Study of Law: Tradition, Forms of Life, and Metaphor, Erasmus Law Review March 2011 (2011) Meergelaagdheid van rechtsordes: oude wijn in nieuwe zakken?, Ars Aequi, 2011/10, pp (2010) The Case bound Character of Legal reasoning, in: E.T. Feteris, H. Kloosterhuis and H.J. Plug, Argumentation and the Application of Legal Rules, Rozenberg Publishers: Amsterdam 2010, pp (2010) Fenomenologie van de gewetensbeslissing: twee varianten, in: A. Ellian, T. Slootweg & C.E. Smith, Recht, beslissing en geweten, Deventer: Kluwer 2010, pp (2010) Rechters maken hun eigen regels, ABG 79, maart 2010, pp (2009) Heuristiek en legitimatie van het rechtsoordeel: van geval naar regel, Trema 2009, pp , (2009) Het belang van de casuïstiek: belangenafweging en vergelijkingsmethode, Trema 2009, pp (2009) De betekenis van de prototypische gevallen voor de rechtsvinding: taalkundige interpretatie, Trema 2009, pp (2009) Het normatieve karakter van de rechtswetenschap: het recht als oordeel, Préadvies voor de Vereniging voor Wijsbegeerte des Rechts, R&R 2009, 38 (3), pp (2009) Soevereiniteit: solipsisme of institutie?, in: G. Molier & T. Slootweg (eds.), Soevereiniteit en recht. Rechtsfilosofische beschouwingen, Den Haag: Boom Juridische uitgevers 2009 (2009) Het woord als grenswachter: functies van taalkundige interpretatie voor de rechtsvinding, Rechtsgeleerd Magazijn Themis, , p

7 7 (2009) Rashomon, of de verschillende versies van de waarheid, Ars Aequi, 2009/03, pp (2009) The Rhetoric of Justification, in: E. Van Alphen, M.G. Bal en C.E. Smith (eds.), The Rhetoric of Sincerity, Stanford CA: Stanford University Press 2009, p (2009) Legitimacy of the ruling, in: N. Huls, M. Adams & J. Bomhoff (eds.), in: The Legitimacy of the Highest Court s Rulings. Judicial Deliberations and Beyond, The Hague: T.M.C. Asser Press 2009, p (2008) Criteria voor goed rechtswetenschappelijk onderzoek: de omgekeerde route (gezamenlijk artikel deelnemers Talentprogramma o.l.v. C.E. Smith), NJB 2008/12, p (2008) Some Varieties of Linguistic Interpretations, in: E. Pattaro & C. Faralli (Eds.), Ratio Juris, Vol 21, no. 4, Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Oxford 2008, pp (2008) De rechtsstaat: conflict en procedureregels, in: Denkwerk, Cahier EAJ: Den Haag: Ministerie van Justitie 2008, pp (2008) The Preponderance of Decisions over Rules, in: Denkwerk, Cahier EAJ: Den Haag: Ministerie van Justitie 2008, pp (2008) De rechter: onafhankelijk en autonoom?, Ars Aequi 2008, 5, p (2007) Enkele varianten van taalkundige argumentatie, in: E.T. Feteris e.a. (red.), Alles afwegende, Ars Aequi Libri 2007, p (2007) Sincerity in Legal Argumentation Theory, Proceedings of the 22nd IVR World Congress Granada Volume V, Archiv für Rechts und Sozialphilosophie, ARSP Beihefte 2007, pp (2006) Belangenafweging door gevalsafweging, Themis 2006, 4, p (2005) The Significance of Facts for Judicial Interpretation and the Legitimation of Legal Verdicts, in: Svein Eng (ed.), Proceedings of the 21st IVR World Congress, ARSP Beiheft 97, Franz Steiner Verlag: Stuttgart 2005, p (2004) Regels, beginselen en de valkuilen van de retoriek, in: E.T. Feteris e.a. (red.), In het licht van deze overwegingen, Nijmegen: AA Libri 2004, p (2003) De beperkte betekenis van deugden als juridische categorie, in: P.B. Cliteur & H M.Th. D. ten Napel (red.), Rechten, plichten, deugden, Nijmegen: Ars Aequi Libri 2003, p (2001) De sirenenzang van de esthetiek, in: P.B. Cliteur e.a. (red.), It ain t necessarily so (Franken bundel), Deventer: Kluwer 2001, p

8 8 (2001) Sociale cohesie, mensenrechten en juridisch fundamentalisme, in: P.B. Cliteur & V. van den Eeckhout (red.), Multiculturalisme, cultuurrelativisme en sociale cohesie, Den Haag: Boom Juridische uitgevers 2001, p (2000) Redelijke argumentatie in een pluriforme samenleving, in: E.T. Feteris e.a. (red.), Met recht en rede, Nijmegen: Ars Aequi Libri 2000, p (1997) Hermeneutiek, in: P.B. Cliteur, B.C. Labuschagne & C.E. Smith (red.), Rechtsfilosofische stromingen van de twintigste eeuw, Gouda: Gouda Quint 1997, p (1997) Nawoord, in: P.B. Cliteur, B.C. Labuschagne & C.E. Smith (red.), Rechtsfilosofische stromingen van de twintigste eeuw, Gouda 1997, p (1997) De legistische erfenis: clear en hard cases, in: E.T. Feteris e.a. (red.), Op goede gronden, Nijmegen: Ars Aequi Libri 1997, p (1994) Literaire interpretatie als ontoereikende metafoor voor rechtsvinding, in: E.T. Feteris e.a., Met redenen omkleed, Nijmegen: Ars Aequi Libri 1994, p (1993) Immanuel Kant, in: P.B. Cliteur, A.A.M. Kinneging & G.A. van der List (red.), Filosofen van het klassieke liberalisme, Kampen: Agora 1993, p